Nation-Building.org homepage contact us
Rate Your Nation Book: The Freedom Doctrine Related Links Contact


Policy Implications for Nation-Building Levels

Now that we have rated a nation’s performance at nation-building we can begin to consider policy implications at each level

LEVELS IMPLICATIONS
5. Leader
 

(Facilitator)
Cultural Relating: When nations engage in processing for mutual benefit with other cultures it allows for the resources of each nation to help realize the goals of the other. Thinking about and with other nations to solve problems and take advantage of opportunities results in mutual benefits.

Economic Enterprise: When entrepreneurial-driven free enterprise is supported then people are motivated to apply themselves and deliver economic and social benefits for themselves and others.

Governance Support: With direct democratic governance, everyone is empowered to participate directly in setting governance policies and in directing government programs. This supports the generation and implementation of “great new ideas.”

4. Contributor
 

(Additive)
Cultural Relating: Nations that work helpfully with other cultures can “add” to each others cultures, wealth and prosperity. Good intentions can lead to good results however “Generative Thinking” and a dedication to “mutual benefits” at the level above this one can lead to fantastic levels of mutual growth.

Economic Enterprise: When capitalistic economies, including New Capital Development Systems, motivate people to apply their energies to develop and deliver useful products and services, benefits may accrue for everyone. Participants in traditional capitalistic economies would be further motivated and enabled by the entrepreneurial-driven free enterprise of the level of economic enterprise above this one.

Governance Support: Representative democratic governments enable people to have their voices heard through the representative they elect to create a nation of laws. Representative democratic governments also organize “independent judiciaries” to ensure freedom and justice for their citizens. Direct democracy, at the next higher level, would address the current issues of “non-equitable access to citizen representatives” and the “limits of democracy by representation.”

3. Participant
  (Interchangeable)

 

Cultural Relating: When nations assume they can act autonomously and unilaterally in relation to other cultures, they are operating on a razor’s edge. Autonomy is, at best, a fantasy—no nation has all the resources, within its’ own borders, that its’ citizens want or need. National policies may attempt to keep from stepping on the rights and opportunities of other nations and the citizens of those other nations however this is ultimately an impossible balancing act. Just as relationships are among people—relationships are never on “hold,” they are either growing or they are deteriorating.

Economic Enterprise: Mixed economies include both capitalistic (private ownership of business) and command (national ownership, national subsidies, national tariffs). These are usually “transitional economic practices” moving economies from command and control towards capitalistic and ultimately entrepreneurially-driven free-market economies. The “command” responses (national ownership, national subsidies, national tariffs) may protect jobs for the short-term but ultimately are not viable long-term economic solutions.

Governance Support: Mixed representative and authoritarian governance may be temporarily helpful in times of crisis however, authoritarianism is ultimately anti-human. As within a family, parents may, for a time, make decisions for their children, ultimately, however, children must be empowered with knowledge and skills and set free to govern their own lives and make their own decisions.

 
2. Subtractor
 

(Subtractive)

Cultural Relating: Some nations may decide to relate with other nations or cultures by preventing growth activities. When two nations decide to relate with each other in this way, they are at a point of critical decision-making: to end detractive activities and relate either as autonomous nations (impossible to sustain), or relate as helpful and growthful nations in the global community; or decide to spiral into large-scale violent conflict with other nations.

Economic Enterprise: Command economies dictate specific initiatives. These policies ultimately destroy an economy by destroying the motivation of its people to apply their minds and hearts to work.

Governance Support: Selective authoritarian control by governments selectively limit citizen participation. Citizens may be incarcerated or worse for disagreeing with the authoritarian state. This form of government sows the seeds of its own destruction by its own citizens.

1. Detractor
 

(Destroyer)

Cultural Relating: Any nation that decides to relate with another nation by destroying the rights and freedoms of the citizens of another nation has chosen violence as its way of life. Violent relating is a short-term behavioral pattern. Both victors and victims loose valued life and resources. Ultimately, existence itself requires deciding to adopt levels of cultural relating that involve mutually growful activities.

Economic Enterprise: Control economies dictate all initiatives. Personal motivation for economic activity is crushed in all but a few ideologues.

Governance Support: “Detractor Nations” cannot allow intelligent, people to survive within their “police-states”. Their citizens "go underground and wait," "take their chances with non-violent demonstrations," or “take up arms,” against tyranny.


© 2003, The Nation-Building Group